Early versus late necrosectomy in severe necrotizing pancreatitis

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0002-9610(96)00425-4Get rights and content

Abstract

Background

Debate as to whether surgery in severe necrotizing pancreatitis (SNP) should be done early or late has been present ever since the disease was described. There are no prospective, randomized studies addressing this specific issue.

Methods

Patients with SNP, documented clinically, with Ranson's criteria, and dynamic pancreatography (DP) findings were randomly allocated in two groups for treatment. Group A included early necrosectomy (within 48 to 72 hours of onset) and group B, late necrosectomy (at least 12 days after onset). Both groups continued with open packing and staged necrosectomies. Cultures were obtained at each laparotomy and necrosis was verified histologically in all instances.

Results

During a 36-month study period, 150 patients with unequivocal acute pancreatitis were admitted for treatment. Forty-one with SNP initially entered the study; there were 5 drop outs. Patients in group A (25) and group B (11) had no difference in distribution by gender or mean age, etiology, mean Ranson's signs (4 versus 3.8), DP findings, rate of infected necrosis, or necrosectomies required per patient. Although the mortality rate (56% versus 27%) did not reach statistical significance, the odds ratio for mortality was 3.4 times higher in group A, which made us finish the study.

Conclusion

This prospective, randomized study from a single institution clearly demonstrates that early intensive conservative treatment with late necrosectomy for selected cases is the current rationale approach for SNP.

References (30)

  • FoitzikT et al.

    Time course of bacterial infection of the pancreas and its relation to disease severity in a rodent model of acute necrotizing pancreatitis

    Ann Surg.

    (1994)
  • WiddisonAL et al.

    Surgical intervention in acute pancreatitis: when and how

    Pancreas.

    (1991)
  • MachadoMC et al.

    Sur-gical treatment of pancreatic necrosis

    Dig Dis Sci.

    (1986)
  • SennN

    The Surgery of the Pancreas as Based Upon Experiments and Clinical Researches

  • FitzRH

    Acute pancreatitis: a consideration of pancreatic hem-orrhage, hemorrhagic, suppurative, and gangrenous pancreatitis, and of disseminated fat-necrosis

    Boston Med Surg J.

    (1889)
    FitzRH

    Acute pancreatitis: a consideration of pancreatic hem-orrhage, hemorrhagic, suppurative, and gangrenous pancreatitis, and of disseminated fat-necrosis

    Boston Med Surg J.

    (1889)
    FitzRH

    Acute pancreatitis: a consideration of pancreatic hem-orrhage, hemorrhagic, suppurative, and gangrenous pancreatitis, and of disseminated fat-necrosis

    Boston Med Surg J.

    (1889)
  • FitzRH

    The symptomatology and diagnosis of diseases of the pancreas

  • MoynihanB

    Acute pancreatitis

    Ann Surg.

    (1925)
  • SchmeidenV et al.

    Surgery of the pancreas; with es-pecial consideration of acute pancreatic necrosis

    Surg Gynecol Ob-stet.

    (1928)
  • ElmanR et al.

    Value of blood amylase es-timations in the diagnosis of pancreatic disease

    Arch Surg.

    (1929)
  • MercadierM

    Surgical treatment of acute pancreatitis: tactics, techniques, and results

    World J

    (1981)
  • AldridgeMC et al.

    Pancreatic resection for severe acute pancreatitis

    Br J Surg.

    (1985)
  • BegerHG et al.

    Necrosectomy and postoperative local lavage in patients with necrotizing pancrea-titis: results of a prospective clinical trial

    World J Surg.

    (1988)
  • OrlandoR et al.

    Techniques and complica-tions of open packing of infected pancreatic necrosis

    Surg Gynecol Obstet.

    (1993)
  • RansonJHC

    Conservative surgical treatment of acute pancreatitis

    World J Surg.

    (1981)
  • HowardJM

    Delayed débridement and external drainage of massive pancreatic or peripancreatic necrosis

    Surg Gynecol Obstet.

    (1989)
  • Cited by (0)

    View full text